The other day I thought about that game we sometimes play with our best friends, our spouses, our siblings. “Would you still love me if…?” Would you still love me if I had feathers for eye brows? Would you still love me if I had ears for eyes and eyes for ears? Would you still love me if I walked like this? And then we turn our feet at unnatural angles and bounce about in the most embarrassing way we can imagine. They’ll roll their eyes and we laugh it off, but it struck me that what we’re really asking is just - Do you love me now? Not with elbows for knees, or if I had flamingo legs, but right here with all my actual flaws and imperfections. Do you take it all in and still desire to draw me close? When I’m angry or obviously insecure, when I’m over-the-top over-joyed about something and bubbling over with too much energy. Do you still love me then? When I snap with impatience, or when I laugh at the wrong time, or when I say the wrong thing, do you still love me in that moment?
It’s natural that we should ask that. It’s a fundamental human desire to be loved so fully that every corner of who we are is covered in that grace. We struggle to love ourselves in such a way, so we doubt. How could anyone else possibly accomplish it?
I’ve been fortunate to have many relationships in my lifetime, most of them dear friendships, where I never had reason to doubt that I was loved like that. In good times, in dark times, their steadfastness proved it - that yes, I am loved in all my brokenness, imperfections and annoying habits. Yet I go on asking the question: “would you still love me if…?” Would you still love me if I messed up? If I forgot your birthday, or hurt you, or acted selfishly in our relationship? Could you find a way to love me even then?
Each time we ask that question it feels like a drop in the well. Maybe if we ask enough, we can fill it and move on in assurance of how deeply loved we are. It’s a trap we fall into, thinking we can satisfy that doubt. We’re really just positioning ourselves to drown. The questions pile up over our heads and the walls of the well become slick with their inability to satisfy us. Our insecurities sink into our bones, making us heavy, pulling us to the bottom, choking out reassuring responses. Even in the most secure relationships I’ve had, I found I could go on asking that question forever.
Yet there is one who can provide a satisfactory answer to that bottomless question. We see the proof of it hanging bloody on a tree. We feel the truth of it in His hands and side, split open and raw. We hear the reality of it in the silence of an empty tomb. We taste it in broken bread and smell it in cups of wine.
Will you still love me if I sin again? Will you still love me when I sin the same way again?
When I whittle it down for myself, the deepest version of that question is at the same time simple and vast. "Will you still love me when I am unloveable?" Our deepest fear, laid naked in our hands. Yet over and over, He will come close to answer, "Not only will I always love you, I have always loved all of you." The Creator of the Universe, holy and unblemished, leans down to not only save us, but sing over us. To not only sustain us, but to Father us. He looks at every last shred of who we are and says, “She is mine. He is mine. I want all of who they are."
From before the foundation of the earth, He not only knew us, but loved us. Who else could answer that deepest question in us, but the one who gave up everything to get us back?
As many times as we need to ask it, the answer will not change. Perhaps one day, we will experience it in such a way we will actually dare to believe it. This is important. It sets us free. When we no longer walk in the fear of proving our doubts correct, we are able to offer that unconditional love to others. We are ministers of God’s compassion, agents of grace, meant to mirror His character in our reflective image-bearing. It’s so much easier to do that when we understand that we are not only loved, but delighted in. When insecurity no longer asks us to constantly prove ourselves, we can finally see each other. Over time, the focus moves from "Do you still love me?" to "How can I love you?"
And then we get to take part in something eternal. We get to offer that safe landing pad we've been given to answer that inquiry.
Yes, you are loved.